Hazard Adams’ “Critical
Theory Since Plato”
Introduction
Hazard Adams’ Critical Theory
Since Plato serves as a compendium of literary theories spanning from
the classical era to modernity, offering a panoramic view of how critical
perspectives on literature have evolved over centuries. The text’s strength
lies not only in its breadth but also in its detailed exploration of the
philosophical and cultural underpinnings of each theoretical framework. This
essay critically examines the significance of Adams’ work in tracing the
trajectory of literary criticism and the intersections of philosophy, art, and
culture that define it.
The Classical Foundations of
Critical Thought
Adams begins with the seminal
contributions of Plato and Aristotle, whose ideas form the
cornerstone of Western literary theory. Plato’s skepticism toward poetry,
rooted in his metaphysical commitment to ideal forms, establishes the enduring
tension between art and truth. His critique of poetry as an imitation of an
imitation challenges the ethical and epistemological value of art. Adams
presents Plato’s ideas as a precursor to moralistic critiques of literature,
which resurface across history, from Renaissance Puritanism to Marxist and
feminist critiques.
In contrast, Aristotle’s Poetics
offers a pragmatic counterpoint, emphasizing the cathartic and structural
dimensions of literature. His delineation of tragedy as an art form capable of
eliciting pity and fear introduces a critical lexicon that resonates in modern
formalist and structuralist approaches. Adams highlights how these foundational
theories establish the binary between art’s aesthetic autonomy and its societal
function, a theme that persists in subsequent critical traditions.
From Romanticism to
Modernity: Shifting Paradigms
Adams meticulously traces the Romantic
revolution, which radically reoriented literary criticism toward the expressive
and imaginative faculties of the artist. The Romantic focus on individuality
and creativity, epitomized by Wordsworth and Coleridge, marks a
departure from the classical emphasis on mimetic realism. Adams contextualizes
this shift within broader cultural currents, including Enlightenment
rationalism and the subsequent Romantic reaction against it.
The Romantic elevation of the artist as
a quasi-divine creator finds echoes in later existentialist and psychoanalytic
theories. For instance, Adams draws parallels between Romantic subjectivity
and Freud’s concept of the unconscious, as both prioritize inner
experience over external reality. Similarly, the Romantic valorization of
imagination prefigures modernist experimentation with form and language.
Modern and Postmodern
Critiques
Adams’ treatment of 20th century
critical theory underscores the fragmentation and pluralism that characterize contemporary
literary studies. The rise of formalism and structuralism in the early 20th
century signals a return to Aristotle’s objective approach but with a renewed
emphasis on language and textual systems. Adams deftly navigates the transition
from structuralism to post-structuralism, highlighting figures like Derrida and
Foucault who challenge the stability of meaning and the coherence of
authorial intent.
Postmodernism, as
Adams illustrates, problematizes the very foundations of critical theory by
questioning the possibility of universal truths or stable interpretive
frameworks. His discussion of postmodern critiques, including deconstruction,
foregrounds the inherent contradictions and multiplicities within texts.
However, Adams also acknowledges the critiques leveled against postmodernism
for its perceived nihilism and detachment from material realities.
The Interdisciplinary Turn
A notable strength of Adams’ anthology
is its recognition of the increasingly interdisciplinary nature of literary
theory. By incorporating perspectives from Marxism, feminism,
psychoanalysis, and postcolonial theory, Adams highlights the
intersections of literature with social, political, and psychological
discourses. These approaches extend the scope of literary criticism beyond the
text, emphasizing its role in interrogating power structures, identities, and
ideologies.
Conclusion
Hazard Adams’ Critical Theory
Since Plato is an invaluable resource for understanding the historical
and philosophical evolution of literary criticism. By presenting a
chronological and thematic overview of critical theories, Adams elucidates the
dynamic interplay between literature, philosophy, and culture.
His anthology invites readers to engage critically with the shifting paradigms
of literary thought, encouraging a nuanced appreciation of the ways in which
literature reflects and shapes human experience.
In its breadth and depth, Adams’ work
underscores the enduring relevance of literary criticism as a
discipline that not only interprets art but also interrogates the cultural and
intellectual currents that inform it. It challenges contemporary
scholars to continue the dialogue, bridging past insights with emerging
critical perspectives in an ever-changing literary landscape.
*****
